Oreo Pie - The Stay At Home Chef

Calling all serious Oreo fans! Introducing Oreo Pie: a delectable fusion of creamy pie and crunchy cookies that brings your favorite treat to a whole new level of indulgence. Crafted from scratch, this indulgent treat begins with a rich, homemade Oreo crust, providing a sturdy foundation for the pièce de résistance: a luscious, airy layer of velvety smooth Oreo filling infused with an ideal balance of Oreo’s signature flavors. For a truly indulgent treat, why not take it to the next level by adding even more Oreo goodness and finishing it off with an extra layer of crunchy cookie pieces?

Contents

Why Our Recipe Ingredient Notes Topping Ideas Storage Instructions

Why Our Recipe

Craving a homemade take on the classic Oreo crust? Try this ingenious hack that requires only two humble ingredients!
Using heavy cream instead of Cool Whip ensures the most authentic and rich taste in this recipe.
Explore a world of creative possibilities by experimenting with unique flavors of Oreos to elevate your pie-making experience and bring a twist of excitement to the traditional dessert.

Whether celebrating a milestone, observing a festive holiday, or simply satisfying a sweet tooth, this indulgent pie is the ideal choice for any gathering. With its effortless, no-bake filling, you can conjure this treat at a moment’s notice. Join us for a taste adventure on the dark side and indulge in a rich, decadent Oreo Pie experience that will leave you craving more.

Ingredient Notes

oreo pie ingredients on a kitchen counter

A total of 36 Oreos will be required to assemble both the pie crust and the filling. Crush the entire Oreo to fully release its rich flavors and textures. Feel free to choose your favorite Oreo flavor!
Whether you choose unsalted or salted butter makes little difference in this context. Ensure the butter is fully melted and warm to the touch before incorporating it into the crushed Oreos for optimal results.
You can choose from our regular options, as well as lighter versions with reduced fat content.
This smooths out the Oreo filling without a hint of grittiness.
Both heavy whipping cream and heavy cream are suitable substitutes for whipping, thanks to their identical fat content.

Topping Ideas

Enhance your dessert with a drizzle of rich caramel or velvety chocolate sauce for an indulgent finish. Add an extra layer of indulgence by incorporating melted chocolate into your recipe for an intense, sweet treat!

Adding chopped nuts such as peanuts, almonds, or walnuts will not only complement the flavors but also provide a satisfying textural contrast with their crunchy bite.

A crunchy alternative: consider substituting chopped pretzels for nut crunch.

Add a drizzle of warm peanut butter to the top, allowing its creamy, nutty essence to harmonize with the dark chocolate in a sublime, indulgent fusion.

Let’s add some sparkles to this plain text!

Storage Instructions

Stored leftover pie in an airtight container at room temperature for 2 to 3 days.

Wrap the pie securely in plastic wrap, followed by a layer of aluminium foil, to effectively shield it from freezer burn. Store this item in the freezer at a temperature of -18°C (0°F) or below for a period of up to three months. To thaw a pie, simply refrigerate it overnight or allow it to sit at room temperature for about an hour.