Frog Eye Salad – Cookies and Cups

Frog Eye Salad is a sweet summer salad with fruit, custard, whipped topping, and pasta! It’s a texture and flavor delight, and is the perfect side dish recipe for your summer BBQ!

Easy Frog Eye Salad Recipe

Don’t worry there aren’t ACTUALLY frog eyes in this salad! In the world of unconventional dessert creations, Frog Eye Salad is definitely close to the top of the list.

With its quirky name and unique blend of ingredients, this true potluck-style salad always gets people talking. Frog Eye Salad is a classic, dessert salad, a lot like ambrosia, that combines a variety of flavors and textures. It is a great option for BBQs and summer get togethers instead of a simple fruit salad.

Why You’ll Love This Frogs Eye Salad Recipe

• Simple. All of the ingredients in this recipe are super easy to find and making the actual salad is a cinch!
• Creamy & delicious. Every bite of this frogged eye salad recipe is creamy and flavorful. I love the tender pasta mixed with creamy sauce and bursts of sweetness from the fruit.
• Conversation starter. Let me tell you, every time I make this salad for a potluck or family gathering it gets people talking!

Why Is It Called Frog Eye Salad?

Originally created in the 1960s, the name itself is derived from the small, round pasta used in the dish, resembling the little frog eyes. I’d say it’s a leap (no pun intended), but I guess you have to come up with a name…and when in doubt, get creative! This salad is also called “frogs eye salad,” “frog eyed salad” and “frogged eye salad.”

The blend of textures is what makes this salad special. The pasta provides a soft and chewy element that contrasts beautifully with the creamy base made up of a homemade custard, whipped topping, and fruit. 

Recipe Ingredients

Here’s a quick overview of what you’ll need to make frog eyed salad. Be sure to scroll down to the recipe card for the full ingredient list.

• Fruit: Crushed Pineapple, Pineapple Chunks (aka Pineapple Tidbits), Mandarin Oranges.
• Dry Ingredients: Granulated Sugar, Kosher Salt, Cornstarch.
• Wet Ingredients: Pineapple Juice, an Egg Yolk.
• Pasta: Acini Di Pepe or Ditalini.
• Add Ins: Miniature Marshmallows and Shredded sweetened coconut, Cool Whip.

What Type Of Pasta Do You Use In Frog Eye Salad?

Most recipes that I have see over the years include Acini di Pepe Pasta, most commonly referred to as Pastina. These days, Pastina can be difficult to find, so I used Ditalini, which is readily available. But just note that you are free to use whatever type you can as long as they are round, if you want to stay true to the whole “Frog Eye” vibe. 

How To Make Frog Eye Salad

Are you ready to make the best frogged eye salad ever? Here’s a quick overview:

• Make the custard. In a small saucepan over medium heat whisk pineapple juice, sugar, egg yolk, salt, and cornstarch together. Cook this until it comes to a low boil and thickens up. Set it aside to cool while you prep the remaining ingredients. 
• Cook the pasta. Simply boil the pasta according to the package directions, but don’t salt the water. Cook until al dente and drain and cool the pasta completely. 

• Mix together the cooled pasta and custard. Refrigerate this and allow it to set for at least 2 hours, or overnight it great too. This step is great to do in advance. The pasta and custard will thicken, creating a nice base for the salad.

• Assemble. In a large bowl, stir the pineapple chunks, crushed pineapple, mandarin oranges, coconut, and marshmallows in to the chilled pasta mixture until evenly combined. Fold in the cool whip and either serve immediately, or chill until ready to serve. 

Can You Make Frog Eye Salad In Advance?

This is a great salad to make in advance. You can prep the custard and pasta mixture in advance, or prep the whole salad in advance of serving. Simply store it in the fridge until you’re ready to serve!

Variations Ideas

There are some common ingredients that you see in variations of this salad recipe. Here are a few ideas for additional add-ins:

• Other kinds of fruit. I recommend maraschino cherries or sliced grapes.
• Chopped nuts. Like pecans or walnuts.
• Orange zest or lemon zest. Both of these options would amp up the citrus vibe.
• Instant Vanilla Pudding. If you want to skip the homemade custard step.
• Homemade whipped cream. You can use this instead of Cool Whip if you prefer! 

How To Serve Frog Eye Salad

This is the ultimate BBQ summer side dish recipe. I love it in the warmer temperatures because of the tropical flavors involved like pineapple and coconut. However this works as an accompaniment to any holiday table, like Thanksgiving or Christmas.

How To Store

Store any leftovers of this salad in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. I don’t recommend freezing this salad.

More Summer Side Dish Recipes

Print

PIN for later: