Herbed Butter Mashed Potatoes

Mashed potatoes – a comfort food that brings people together! With fresh twists from basil, fennel, and garlic, this elevated take on the classic side dish concludes in a rich, buttery harmony with a chive drizzle. These bites boast an incredibly rich flavor profile, and what’s more, their versatility allows for effortless preparation well in advance. You’ll undoubtedly fall head over heels for the simplicity and rich flavour of these velvety mashed potatoes, and we won’t be surprised at all if they become a staple in your household, prompting numerous requests for repeat performances.

Contents

Why Our Recipe Ingredient Notes Make Ahead Option Storage and Reheating Instructions

Why Our Recipe

Transform humble mashed potatoes into an indulgent delight by infusing them with the brightness of fresh herbs, the pungency of roasted garlic, and the richness of melted butter.
Can be prepared through to 3 days in advance: Assemble the salad and store it in an airtight container; keep refrigerated at 40°F (4°C) or below. Dress just before serving.
Buttermilk and cream cheese combine to imbue these mashed potatoes with an ultra-creamy texture and a subtle tanginess that elevates their flavor profile.

By incorporating just a handful of additional elements, you’ll effortlessly elevate mashed potatoes from their humble supporting role to the main attraction. These extraordinary mashed potatoes will astound you with their exceptional taste, requiring only a minimal increase in effort compared to your standard recipes. With its exceptional balance of flavors and simplicity in preparation, this recipe effortlessly elevates the culinary experience to a level typically reserved for fine dining establishments.

Ingredient Notes

An overhead view of whole unpeeled potatoes next to measuring cups and spoons holding wet and dry ingredients needed to make herbed butter mashed potatoes.

Russet potatoes are particularly well-suited for mashing because of their naturally high starch levels, which help maintain a light and airy texture. Consider substituting Yukon Gold potatoes for a delicious and nutritious option.
This method expertly infuses rich, vibrant flavors into your creamy mashed potatoes. Consider reserving the rich, savory broth for use as a base in a future soup or stew. You can also utilize bouillon cubes according to the package instructions.
When using garlic for cooking, it’s essential to use fresh bulbs to achieve the most robust and aromatic flavour. Utilize 1/2 teaspoon of garlic powder, but take advantage of the opportunity to use freshly minced garlic if feasible.
These culinary delights truly reach exceptional standards.
Without buttermilk, no problem? Check out our helpful guide to buttermilk substitutes and discover a simple solution.
These potatoes truly showcase their creamy essence, with the added flavour expertly amplifying their smooth, velvety texture further.
Fresh chives inject a vibrant splash of colour and subtle onion essence, elevating any dish with their delicate charm. You can substitute dried chives for fresh ones, just be sure to use only half the recommended amount.

With a hand mixer, we achieve silky smooth potatoes that defy expectations in terms of creaminess and lightness; however, alternative methods will still yield delicious results. Discover Your Ideal Mash with Ease

To achieve a coarser, heartier consistency, a trusty handheld masher proves the perfect tool for the job. This innovative gadget preserves certain textures, infusing your mashed potatoes with a warm, inviting quality reminiscent of homemade cooking.

Employing a hand mixer yields an exceptionally creamy and silky texture, ideal for those seeking a rich and indulgent dessert experience. The low-speed setting effectively incorporates air, yielding a light and airy texture. To ensure optimal results, maintain a moderate pace while mixing to prevent excessive incorporation of air.

To achieve an exceptionally smooth and restaurant-worthy mashed potato experience, a high-recommended option is to utilize a potato ricer. The ricer’s mechanism carefully squeezes the potatoes through its precisely crafted fine holes, producing a smooth, uniform consistency with no noticeable lumps.

For large batches, a stand mixer efficiently produces a silky-smooth mash in a remarkably short period of time. Ensure you mix the potatoes at a low speed to avoid them becoming glue-like and developing an unpleasant texture.

This tool produces a remarkably smooth finish, yet requires careful handling: pulse the motor in short, controlled intervals to prevent over-processing and ensure optimal results. Excessive processing can result in an unpleasantly sticky texture.

An overhead view of a plate filled with a serving of herbed butter mashed potatoes with a fork set in for eating.

Make Ahead Option

This versatile recipe lends itself perfectly to being prepared in advance. One of the most appealing aspects of mashed potatoes is their versatility; they can be prepared in advance with minimal fuss, then simply reheated when needed, making them an ideal choice for stress-free event planning.

Before moving on to step 4, ensure that your cooled potatoes have been transferred to a baking dish, allowing them to rest for a brief period before being covered and refrigerated. Preheat your oven to 425°F (220°C). Cook the potatoes for approximately 30 minutes, or until they’re evenly heated and hot throughout. Now, preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C). Mashed potatoes can be prepared up to two days in advance.

Storage and Reheating Instructions

Stored leftovers in airtight containers at room temperature for up to four days.

Store leftover portions in airtight containers. Thaw in the refrigerator overnight.

Portion the ingredients into the microwave-safe bowl and heat them on high for 30 seconds at a time, stirring between each interval, until the desired level of doneness is achieved.

Where Rachel expertly guides you through each meticulous step of this delectable recipe, ensuring a seamless culinary experience. With the ability to visualize the process, our cooking show provides a comprehensive culinary experience. Visit our website to access the comprehensive recipe collection, available at and.