Swirling with a medley of mix-ins – crunchy cookie pieces, gooey toffee bits, toasted coconut flakes, rich peanut butter cups, and earthy pecans – this indulgent vanilla ice cream is an unapologetic celebration of flavors, overflowing with delightful surprises in every bite.

Kitchen Sink Ice Cream
While whipping up a batch of Kitchen Sink cookies for a family gathering, my friend Lynne posed an intriguing question: Have you ever attempted to craft a Kitchen Sink Ice Cream? Thank you very much for the challenge accepted and thank you thank you.
Indulge in this sumptuous treat, bursting with an unparalleled array of flavors: rich vanilla ice cream generously swirled with chunky cookie pieces, crunchy toffee bits, toasted coconut flakes, and a medley of indulgent mix-ins, including peanut butter cups and pecans – the perfect haven for those with an insatiable sweet tooth.


Wacky flavors abound in this quirky shop’s “everything but the kitchen sink” ice cream. From classic combos like chocolate and vanilla to more unusual pairings such as maple bacon and strawberry balsamic, each unique scoop is a true adventure for taste buds.
Ben & Jerry’s describes their ‘everything but the kitchen sink ice cream’ as “A Collision of Chocolate & Vanilla Ice Creams mixed with Peanut Butter Cups, Fudge-Covered Toffee Pieces, White Chocolatey Chunks & Fudge-Covered Almonds”.
We’re glad you enjoy your own homemade ice cream, but let’s give credit where credit is due – we were the ones who pioneered this beloved treat! Cookies – our treats feature an assortment of indulgent options, including the delightful combination of cookies and toasted coconut.
The liberating aspect of crafting this dish at home lies in its malleability, allowing you to personalize it by incorporating your preferred ingredients and eliminating those that don’t align with your tastes. Would a subtle crunch of toasted almonds elevate the flavor profile and add depth to the dish? Go on and add them! Not so keen on coconut? Kick it to the curb!

To craft a sundae that embodies the phrase “a little bit of everything,” you’ll require the following comprehensive assortment of ingredients:
- heavy cream
- whole milk
- sugar
- kosher salt
- vanilla extract
Any or all of the preceding ingredients
- cookies
- nuts
- coconut
- miniature chocolate chips
- toffee bits
- miniature m&ms
- miniature peanut butter cups
- chopped candy bars
- sprinkles

Combining the rich cream, pure milk, granulated sugars, pinch of salt, and subtle essence of vanilla extract in a spacious bowl, I whisk them together seamlessly until they’re fully incorporated. Allow the mixture to flow smoothly into your ice cream maker, then proceed to churn it in accordance with the manufacturer’s guidelines.
As you await the conclusion of the ice cream’s churning cycle, take this opportunity to curate a selection of two cups’ worth of preferred mix-ins. Upon completing the churning process, transfer a portion of the freshly made ice cream to an airtight container, liberally sprinkling in the variety of mix-ins. Consume the layers in succession until the remaining ice cream and mix-ins are fully incorporated.
Store in the freezer at your convenience. Served with optional extras of your choice: cookies and toppings.

Homemade Ice Cream Recipes
With a vast collection of over 100 ice cream recipes at your fingertips, you’ll undoubtedly find the perfect scoop for any palate. For those just beginning their ice cream-making journey, a classic and straightforward vanilla recipe is an ideal starting point.
Here are my top picks for affordable storage solutions that keep ice cream fresh: Perfectly crafted to delight recipients as a thoughtful gift, these containers excel at storing and reusing, making them an ideal choice for those who adore the sweet pleasure of homemade ice cream? I mark the flavor labels on the jar tops using a permanent marker, which easily wipes away with gentle dish soap and water.
With an assortment of ice cream scoops that’s grown overwhelming, I’ve developed a clear hierarchy in my affections. This high-performance ice cream scoop excels at effortlessly slicing through even the most stubborn ice cream, consistently yielding perfectly portioned scoops with minimal effort required. As a pleasant surprise, this scoop earns extra points for being one of the most affordable additions to my collection.
Discover the ultimate ice cream maker review, guiding you in selecting the perfect device for your preferences. A shocking revelation awaits – our top pick under $50 is sure to astonish! It sure surprised me!

For even more indulgent treats, consider trying our scrumptious Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream. Tender strawberry sweetness harmonizes with the satisfying crunch of golden Oreos, evoking carefree summer days.
Rich and indulgent, each creamy scoop of Twix ice cream is loaded with generous chunks of crunchy cookies, gooey caramel, and velvety chocolate. Discover a sweet surprise in every bite: Twix ice cream that’s sure to delight fans of the iconic candy bar.
Indulge in the decadent delight of our homemade Rocky Road Ice Cream, a rich and velvety blend of chocolate and almond flavors, studded with soft, pillowy marshmallows, toasted almonds, and shards of dark chocolate for added texture and depth.
A total of approximately 1 to 2 cups of your preferred add-ins.
