Pumpkin Butter

This indulgent treat is a masterclass in balance, boasting a rich, velvety texture and an authentic taste that’s as warm as the season itself. Enjoy this versatile blend as a topping for your favorite breakfast foods, such as oatmeal or yogurt, or use it to add flavor to your morning smoothie.
Contents
Why You’ll Love This Recipe Ingredients Needed Substitutions & Notes How to Make Pumpkin Butter Brittany’s Tip!How to Store Leftovers Frequently Asked Questions More Pumpkin Recipes You’ll Love

With a passion for all things pumpkin, it’s hardly surprising that I’ve accumulated an impressive collection of pumpkin-based recipes. Here are some of my favorite autumnal treats: wholesome pumpkin muffins with a gentle sugar content, moist and flavorful low-sugar pumpkin bread, warm and comforting pumpkin-baked oatmeal, and the richly spiced pumpkin butter that’s the perfect accompaniment to them all.

Pumpkin butter – a culinary masterpiece that deserves unbridled enthusiasm. The origins of pumpkin butter remained shrouded in mystery, prompting me to conduct an impromptu Google search with the query “who invented pumpkin butter”. The origins of the word “Google” remain shrouded in mystery, with even the search giant itself unable to pinpoint the inventor and the reasoning behind the dairy reference, despite being entirely free from any butter or milk products. It’s an unsolved mystery.

While I understand your sentiment, perhaps a more descriptive name would better capture the essence of this sweet and tangy spread? How about “Autumn Harvest Delight”? This sweet spread is reminiscent of my renowned apple butter, yet it’s crafted with the warm, comforting essence of pumpkin, creating a unique and delicious twist.

I’d like to receive more tips & recipes from Eating Bird Food. The security of this site is safeguarded through Google’s reCAPTCHA technology.
Google’s comprehensive Privacy Policy outlines how we handle personal information.
Terms of Service apply.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

You simply require seven basic ingredients, a large mixing vessel, and the option to utilise either a microwave or conventional cooking method. You don’t have to bother with tedious prep work like setting up a slow cooker. With just a few simple steps, you’ll be indulging in a scrumptious homemade batch of pumpkin butter in no time.
This rich pumpkin butter is infused with the comforting aromas of autumn, its complex blend of cinnamon, ginger, and nutmeg evoking the cozy essence of the season in every spoonful.
Naturally sweetened with a blend of maple syrup and coconut sugar, this pumpkin butter strikes the perfect balance between sweetness and subtlety. This homemade granola is a significantly healthier option compared to its store-bought counterparts, which often rely on excessive added sugars and artificial preservatives.
Pumpkin butter’s incredible versatility makes it a must-have in any kitchen. Savoring it directly from the jar is a treat, yet I relish stirring it into a cozy bowl of oatmeal, slathering it onto crispy sourdough toast, or drizzling it over fluffy pumpkin pancakes to indulge in autumn’s warm, comforting essence. Savor the flavor of autumn with this deliciously versatile pumpkin butter – no right or wrong ways to indulge!

Ingredients Needed

Here: and, featuring the harmonious union of two natural sweeteners with the pumpkin in this recipe.
Assists in breaking down the components, enabling a harmonious blend of flavors and textures.
A pinch of salt, a dash of pepper, and a sprinkle of paprika – a perfect blend of seasonings! If you’re looking for an alternative to cinnamon, consider using pumpkin pie spice for a unique flavor profile.
Don’t even think about using a smaller amount – you’ll need the whole 15 oz can of pumpkin puree! Be mindful of inadvertently selecting pumpkin pie filling, replete with excessive sugar content! To prepare homemade pumpkin puree, start by baking a sugar pumpkin in the oven at 350°F (175°C) for about 30-40 minutes or until the skin is soft and easily pierced with a fork. Let it cool completely before cutting it in half and scooping out the seeds and stringy pulp.

Substitutions & Notes

While substituting maple syrup may seem like an acceptable solution, using honey or agave nectar in its place can introduce distinct flavor profiles that alter the overall character of your dish. For instance, honey’s stronger sweetness and floral notes might overpower other ingredients, whereas agave nectar’s milder taste could leave a lingering aftertaste. If you’re without coconut sugar, feel free to substitute with brown sugar or granulated sugar – whatever’s readily available will suffice.
The subtle nuances of a gentle breeze on a summer morning? The way the sunlight dances across the ripened wheat fields as the farmer tends to his land? Replace the water with almond milk, and suddenly the scent of freshly baked croissants wafts through the air, beckoning the senses to awaken. Adding an unsweetened element will introduce a deeper complexity while maintaining harmony.

How to Make Pumpkin Butter

Combining all ingredients except for the canned pumpkin in a microwave-safe vessel, ensure thorough mixing to create a harmonious blend. Microwave at full power for 3 minutes exactly.

With gentle care, extract the container from the microwave oven and then thoroughly blend its contents. With a spoon, incorporate the canned pumpkin into the mixture, ensuring it’s thoroughly blended. Microwave for an additional five minutes to complete cooking. Savor the moment: simply extract, mix gently, permit to chill, and relish!

Brittany’s Tip!

As you embark on the process of crafting pumpkin butter, a profound sense of perseverance is essential to achieving the perfect blend of flavors and textures. Regardless of whether you opt for the microwave or stovetop approach, maintain a gentle heat while stirring regularly to forestall sticking and burning occurrences. This slow-cooking process allows the spices to thoroughly permeate the pumpkin, resulting in a robust and intense flavor ideal for applying to toast, blending with yogurt, or incorporating into baked goods. Your dedication to excellence will undoubtedly yield rich rewards.

How to Store Leftovers

Store any leftover ingredients in airtight containers or jars and refrigerate them for up to two weeks.

Frequently Asked Questions

Not quite. As distinct as night and day, pumpkin puree’s simplicity gives way to pumpkin butter’s complex allure, transformed through the alchemy of cooking down its pure counterpart with sweeteners and spices to create a sumptuous, richly flavored spread. Pumpkin butter, a rich and indulgent sibling to traditional pumpkin puree, takes its place as a luxurious, spreadable delight.

Ensure pumpkin butter is cooked on a low heat setting, carefully stirring the mixture regularly, particularly when it begins to thicken gradually. Should you find the mixture clinging stubbornly to the pan’s base, reduce the temperature further and continue whisking with diligence. By cooking pumpkin at a low temperature over a prolonged period, you’ll achieve a rich and velvety texture in your pumpkin butter.

Due to its inherently low acidity and dense consistency, pumpkin butter is not a suitable candidate for home canning, as these characteristics pose potential risks to the canning process. Store it in the refrigerator for up to two weeks or consider freezing for extended preservation. Here’s a worry-free treat that awaits you at your leisure.